Ok so they claim the charge back was on my account, not someone else's. @Prime14k - a charge back is when you make a charge on your creidt card and then later have the bank refuse to pay it. Apparently this can also happen by accident when the charge takes too long to go through from the merchant's end. Which is the only thing I can thimk of that happened in this case.
Anyway, $25 paid and my account is finally back open late tonight. If it weren't for the fact that I enjoy playing the PO freerolls there I might have let this go.