Who do you all think should be rookie of the year? I will go with Andy Dalton.
Printable View
Who do you all think should be rookie of the year? I will go with Andy Dalton.
I agree, Andy Dalton has had a fantastic year. I think Cam will get some votes too.
3 times the charm ... i also agree with u 2. he has been great.
Dalton has been good. But he seemed to struggle without his fellow rookie AJ Greene. So i would think Greene deserves as much credit as dalton
I would have to say even though the Carolina Panthers aren't very goos right now, Cam newton has been a great add to their team and is not to bad as a QB so I can put him in the mix
Andy Dalton is this year's Rookie of the Year and really the surprise of the year. He has taken a bad Bengals team and made them into a contender.
Bart Starr !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Even though it is impossible for him to win this award, I say Jim Harbough. Atleast he will get coach of the year
Cam needs to be more...humble. Andy needs to be more confidant. andy is my pick
confidance*
and note: is that were is mark in this he was some what over rated preseason.
tim is a rookie in my books. and the broncos 4-1 with him starting
Looks like Dalton seems to be the odds on favorite
Cam. Yes he didn't get his team the wins he shouldve but his stats says it all
dalton leads in wins, cam leads in stats, but the season still have 5 games, lets wait and see...
Dalton has done really good, and better than expected. But the whole QB getting all the praise annoys me at times. I mean AJ Greene has made the big plays for dalton when he needed it. And its no suprise they struggled vs baltimore and pittsburgh last 2 games as greene was out.
A QB is only as good as the WR he is throwing too.
Doesn't the Colts' current situation prove that the QB is the most valuable person on a team? You can't tell me with Peyton healthy and playing, the Colts would be anything less than 6-5 at this point, as opposed to their current 0-11 record. Dalton does have some young talented recievers, but not as good as some of the recievers on other teams, like the Packers.
Im not saying dalton is stacked but he has struggled last 2 games without greene. And one of his earlier losses greene was taken away from him by double teams. Game after game he gets alot of attention for great passes, all of which were to greene.
Id challenge ur peyton manning question with what happened when tom brady got injured for the season. Patriots finished with the best record not to make the playoffs in a long time. So if Tom brady who many people think is the greatest ever could be out for a season and them still to have a good record i think there is more to the colts losing than simply manning being out.
stop. there's no denying cam newton here
Von Miller is having a great year for defensive players, easily Defensive Rookie of the Year.
I'm going with Cam Newton too. Dalton and Green have been good, but I think Cam wins.
After their recent performances in the last few weeks, it has become clear that Cam Newton deserves to be the NFL Rookie of the Year this year. Newton has stepped up his incredible pace in the last two weeks and it seems like he is carrying his team on his shoulders, with his running and passing game.
Newton seriously? Anyone who doesn't think he deserves it is just simply stupid, or too arrogant because they dislike Newton. He simply is the best rookie. This week's performance is a testament to that.
I go with Dalton, of course I'm from Ft. Worth,,,the location of TCU ,,, Go Frogs
I respect Dalton, and any other year he would be rookie of the year..... but Cam has done something amazing, especially considering he lead a 2-14 team to a 6-9 record. He took the rookie record for yardage and the record for TD's ran by a QB. It should be easily Newton that receives the award.
To me its hands down Cam Newton. This guy is a stud and one if not the most exciting player in the NFL to watch. Thats my opinion!
Dalton has been good.
I am a bit bias, being a 9ers fan, but Aldon Smith is having a monster year. Rookie sack leader right now, probably will finish out that way (think the rams will stop him lol?). Hopefully he gets Defensive rookie of the year. I don't see anyone on offense beating out Cam, even though I wish someone would lol.
andy dalton is hands down the rookie of the year
im a bengals fan, dalton is good but aj green makes him look really good. that being said, cam newton is the top choice for rookie of the year.
The stats say Cam but Andy Dalton leading his team to the playoffs definitely helps
Cam Newton has the best rookie season in a while, playoffs or not the panthers were a horrible team, horrible defense...they were guarentedd to suck this year...ROY is CAM....Dalton #2 a close #2...i wouldnt be surprised if dalton won....can victor cruz be ROY? or did last year count as a year? idk if he even played a game last year for the giants.....
Victor Cruz might be eligable, im not sure...he has had an excelent season for a WR, record setting season in yards....crazy kid...very happy to see him succeed
even though I hate the giants, but Cam Newton should be a lock, but im just making an agrument for others lmao...#1-Cam Newton, #2 Andy Dalton, #3 AJ Green, #4"Victor Cruz" (if eligable)
Defensive ROY is Aldon Smith on the 49ers should be a lock, or Von Miller on Broncos....could be either one of them...but I think Aldon SMith has the edge since he has the better run towards the end of the season