NFL Rookie of the Year?

[Prawney]

Dalton deserves it more based on him carrying his team to a better record than almost anyone expected. Cam has skills, no doubt about it, but needs to be more of a team player.

Dalton has done really good, and better than expected. But the whole QB getting all the praise annoys me at times. I mean AJ Greene has made the big plays for dalton when he needed it. And its no suprise they struggled vs baltimore and pittsburgh last 2 games as greene was out.

A QB is only as good as the WR he is throwing too.

[CoolJakeB]

Dalton has done really good, and better than expected. But the whole QB getting all the praise annoys me at times. I mean AJ Greene has made the big plays for dalton when he needed it. And its no suprise they struggled vs baltimore and pittsburgh last 2 games as greene was out.

A QB is only as good as the WR he is throwing too.

Doesn't the Colts' current situation prove that the QB is the most valuable person on a team? You can't tell me with Peyton healthy and playing, the Colts would be anything less than 6-5 at this point, as opposed to their current 0-11 record. Dalton does have some young talented recievers, but not as good as some of the recievers on other teams, like the Packers.

[Prawney]

Doesn't the Colts' current situation prove that the QB is the most valuable person on a team? You can't tell me with Peyton healthy and playing, the Colts would be anything less than 6-5 at this point, as opposed to their current 0-11 record. Dalton does have some young talented recievers, but not as good as some of the recievers on other teams, like the Packers.

Im not saying dalton is stacked but he has struggled last 2 games without greene. And one of his earlier losses greene was taken away from him by double teams. Game after game he gets alot of attention for great passes, all of which were to greene.

Id challenge ur peyton manning question with what happened when tom brady got injured for the season. Patriots finished with the best record not to make the playoffs in a long time. So if Tom brady who many people think is the greatest ever could be out for a season and them still to have a good record i think there is more to the colts losing than simply manning being out.