Saw them...ehh...Not my cup of tea! I would give the edge to Hugo. The deciding factor was one big misfortune for a silent movie, If you accidently let one rip in the theater during a silent film, everyone hears. Your azz is busted for at least the immediate rows around you. Now it stinks and everyone is making subtle, yet very descriptive gaffing noises. What would you do?...LMFAO!